Tuesday, August 26, 2014

SOAPTONE Journals of Columbus

SOAPTONE Journals of Columbus

Source  

Who wrote the document?  

Christopher Columbus

What is the author’s background/point of view?   

Christopher Columbus was an Italian that was hired by the Spanish Empire to find a trade route to China. His purpose was to find riches and spices.

Whose point of view, given the topic, is
missing?  

The Natives.

Do you consider the source a reliable one on this topic?  Why/why not?  

No, because he, Columbus, was bias. He was greedy and looking for riches therefore he exaggerated the glory of what he found because he actually didn’t find anything.

Occasion  

When was the document written?  

1492,

What does the date of the document tell you about its content?  

It was during Christopher Columbus’s first attempt at discovering the Americas

What other historical events were going on during this time? 

Spain was united by Ferdinand and Isabella marrying. Spain kicks out all of the Islams. The Treaty of Tordesillas happened during this time as well.


Audience  

To whom is the author writing?  


“ His highness” King Ferdinand.

What type of document is this (diary entry, personal letter, public speech,
etc.)?    

Recording notes of his trip.

Does the private/public nature of the document inform you about its content
(is the author sharing private thoughts, making a public pronouncement,
etc.)?  

The private sense of the personal notes show us that Christopher lied to his men to keep their moral up.

Purpose  
Why was the document written?  What is the purpose of the document?  

The document was written to record Columbus’s trip to the Americas. Towards the end Columbus hints that he hopes to be refunded to make a return trip; planting the seed in the readers mind to give him funding.

What is the document saying?  

The document is asking for money for a return trip.

Tone

What is the attitude of the speaker?


Doubtful in the beginning that soon turns into overly optimistic when land is discovered.

SOAPTONE Letter to Luis de Santangel

Source  

Who wrote the document?  

Christopher Columbus

What is the author’s background/point of view?   

Christopher Columbus an Italian that was hired by the Spanish Empire to find a trade route to China. His purpose was to find riches and spices.

Whose point of view, given the topic, is
missing?  

The Natives

Do you consider the source a reliable one on this topic?  Why/why not?  

No, because he, Columbus, was bias. He was greedy and looking for riches therefore he exaggerated the glory of what he found because he actually didn’t find anything.

Occasion  

When was the document written?  

1493

What does the date of the document tell you about its content?  

This document was written during his return voyage home.

What other historical events were going on during this time? 

Spain kicks out all of the Islams. The Treaty of Tordesillas happened during this time as well.

Audience  

To whom is the author writing?  

The author is directly writing to Luis de Santangel, a priest. He, however, may have realized that it would be published or shared with others causing him to boast more about his discoveries.

What type of document is this (diary entry, personal letter, public speech,
etc.)?    
Personal letter.

Does the private/public nature of the document inform you about its content
(is the author sharing private thoughts, making a public pronouncement,
etc.)?  

This looks like a private letter, but Columbus may have realized that it would be placed in the public’s eye so he did not share private thoughts. Instead he over exaggerated his findings so that he could get funded to go back.

Purpose  
Why was the document written?  What is the purpose of the document?  

The document was written so that Columbus could get funded to go back over to the America’s to find gold and Christianize natives.

What is the document saying?  

He is trying to justify going back to the New World. Christopher is almost desperate for this because he is now out of a job and did not do his previous job correctly.

Tone

What is the attitude of the speaker?


Christopher Columbus is overly optimistic.

SOAPTONE Brief Account of the Devestation of the Indies

Source 

Who wrote the document? 

Bartolome de Las Casas wrote  Brief Account of the Devestation of the Indies (1542)

What is the author’s background/point of view?  

He was a historian and activists for Native Americans. Although, at first he did own slaves and treat them horribly he had a change of heart when he read a sermon Sermon out of a book. He began to preach against the cruelty of the way the Spaniards treat Natives, but was met with resistance.

Whose point of view, given the topic, is 
missing? 

The Natives.

Do you consider the source a reliable one on this topic?  Why/why not? 

Bartolome was clearly writing with his emotions. He was a historian, however, so the numbers of land measurements and populations may be closer to accurate. The rate killed may be over exaggerated because of the way he attached his emotions to his work.

Occasion 

When was the document written? 

1542

What does the date of the document tell you about its content? 

This was 49 years after Columbus’s discovery of the New World.

What other historical events were going on during this time? 

Pope Paul III begins inquisition against Protestants

Audience 

To whom is the author writing? 

The public

What type of document is this (diary entry, personal letter, public speech, 
etc.)?   

Public speech/print

Does the private/public nature of the document inform you about its content 
(is the author sharing private thoughts, making a public pronouncement, 
etc.)? 

He is making a public pronouncement trying to convince them of their wrong doings.

Purpose 
Why was the document written?  What is the purpose of the document? 

The document was written by a priest to document the devastation of the Indies. It was published to advocate on the Natives behalf.

What is the document saying? 

The document is saying that the Spaniards have not done correctly in their treatment of the Natives and they need to treat them better.

Tone

What is the attitude of the speaker?


Batolome is condemning towards the actions of the Spaniards.

Sunday, August 24, 2014

Comparison People's vs. Patriot's

Was Columbus a savage unlike the Native population? Or was he a saint? Both of the books A Patriot’s History of the United States and A People’s History of the United States will try to tell you the answer – their answer.
A People’s History of the United States opens right into the story of the Americas. It does not try and preface with anything that most students simply skip over because usually they are long, boring, and simply trying to reinforce what the text says or how great critic believe the text is. People’s describes the natives with words “naked” (a sign of innocence) and “full of wonder”.  The one descriptive piece they say of Columbus and his crew is that they are carrying swords. While Zinn attempts to show history through the victim’s point of view he may have over exaggerated and used people’s already guilty conscience to paint the Spanish, Europeans, and every other conqueror as a negative force.
On the other side of the scale is A Patriot’s History of the United States an extreme rightest author. This book was basically written for conservatives. Even if you took the title out of the picture the giant American flag on the center of the cover certainly isn’t subtle towards Larry Schweikart and Michael Allen’s bias. They start off the book with a long interview that basically describes how amazing the book is and how the world needed the right Right view of America’s history. This is trying to speak for the book and it’s contents before you even read it. At the end of the interview Schweikart calls the American Historical Review stupid – apparently they didn’t give him a good review. The authors take offense with “the main stream textbooks” and how they fill student with lies about their country. They try to defend their country thereby trying to turn Columbus into an adventurous explorer that had never done any wrong.

One book far to the Left, and the other far to the Right. Somewhere in the middle is the truth.

Thursday, August 21, 2014

Chapter 1 questions

The Shaping of North America
Know:    Appalachian Mountains, Tidewater Region, Rocky Mountains, Great Basin, Great Lakes, Missouri-Mississippi-Ohio River System 

 2.        Speculate how at least one geographic feature affected the development of the United States.

The Appalachian mountains most likely kept the colonists towards the East America to begin with. The steep rocky terrain would be a deterrent for the settlers. This leaves some room for the Natives and slows the settlers movement towards the West. 

Peopling the Americas
Know:    Land Bridge 

 3.        "Before the arrival of Europeans, the settlement of the Americas was insignificant."  Assess this statement.

This statement is false before Europeans the Americas were less densely populated, but they also have thousands of unique cultures and languages. 

  
The Earliest Americans
Know:    Maize, Aztecs, Incas, Pueblo, Mound Builders, Three-sister Farming, Cherokee, Iroquois

4.        Describe some of the common features of North American Indian culture.

They relied mostly upon hunting and gathering for their food source. Men went hunting and women were regarded with a higher standard. Lineage was often passed down along the mother's line. They respected nature and lived in small settlements. 

Indirect Discoverers of the New World
Know: Finland, Crusaders, Venice, Genoa

5.           What caused Europeans to begin exploring?

The Crusades brought home spices from their travels- this ignited the Europeans sweet tooth. The trade routes were all blocked and too expensive to use so Spain sent Christopher Columbus to go try and find a new trade route. 

Europeans Enter Africa
Know:    Marco Polo, Caravel, Bartholomeu Dias, Vasco da Gama, Ferdinand and Isabella, Moors

6.        What were the results of the Portuguese explorations of Africa?

Because the Portuguese developed trading posts along the African route they were able to control who went through and for what price. This caused Spain to search for new routes to the spices- which is why they hired Columbus. This inadvertently found the Americas.
Columbus Comes upon a New World
Know:    Columbus

7.        What developments set the stage for “a cataclysmic shift in the course of history?”

The Europeans taste for spices increased after the Crusades and Marco Polo brought back wonderful stories of China. The Renaissance in the 14th century gave everyone a sense of adventure and optimism. Printing presses were able to circulate press and create hype for adventure. The Mariner's compass eliminated uncertainties for travelers.


When Worlds Collide
Know:    Corn, Potatoes, Sugar, Horses, Smallpox

 8.        Explain the positive and negative effects of the Atlantic Exchange (also known at the Columbian Exchange).

The natives got horses, new culture, small pox and sugar.

The Europeans received tobacco, potatoes, chocolate, and possibly syphilis. 

Both of these groups received a positive element in their exchange. The natives had more of a cultural change whereas the Europeans had a monetary gain. Horses changed the natives ability for movement. For some tribes it allowed them to hunt buffalo and bison better. The Europeans were able to sell tobacco for large amounts of money, and potatoes became a staple food and saved many from starvation. 

However, the Europeans also brought over small pox. This wiped out much of the native population because they did not have the same defenses in their immune system. The natives, disputably, gave the Europeans syphilis. 

The Spanish Conquistadors
Know:    Treaty of Tordesillas, Vasco Nunez Balboa, Ferdinand Magellan, Juan Ponce de Leon, Francisco Coronado, Hernando de Soto, Francisco Pizarro, Encomienda

 9.        Were the conquistadors great men?  Explain.

The Conquistadors arrived in America as great men. They were there to explore, bring back riches to their own country, and convert others to Catholicism. However, greed and power got to their head and they began to think more of the money than religion or peaceful negotiations. They wiped out the Aztec and Inca civilizations and plundered towns to elevate their rank. 

Makers of America: The Spanish Conquistadors
Know:    Granada, Moors, "Reconquista"

10.        Were the conquistadors' motives successfully fulfilled?  Explain.

Yes. Their goal was to gain land and riches for Spain. they did both of those. They did not, however, gain many personal riches.

The Conquest of Mexico
Know:    Hernan Cortes, Tenochtitlan, Montezuma, Mestizos

11.            Why was Cortes able to defeat the powerful Aztecs?

Cortes rescued a Spanish castaway who had learned Mayan during his captivity as a slave with the Indians and a female Indian slave (Malinche). This gave him the ability to translate the Native languages. It also got his troops encouraged that there were actually riches in these hills. The interpreters also told him of the unrest in the Aztec Empire giving Cortes perfect motive and timing to strike out at the Aztecs. When Cortes approached the Aztecs Moctezuma (the Aztec chieftain) believed that Cortes was the god Quetzalcoatl. Who was supposed to return according to the legends. This allowed the conquistadores to arrive at the capitol, Tenochtitlán, uncontested. Once the Aztecs realized that they made a mistake in inviting the conquistadors in they turned them out in a bloody battle. Cortes regrouped and laid siege for a year. By then the Native population had diminished from a smallpox epidemic. This made them weak allowing Cortes and his men to take over for three centuries of Spanish control.

The Spread of Spanish America
Know:    John Cabot, Giovanni da Verazano, Jacques Cartier, St. Augustine, New Mexico, Pope's Rebellion, Mission Indians, Black Legend


12.        What is the “Black Legend,” and to what extent does our text agree with it? (Page 22)

The Black Legend is the belief that the Spanish brought nothing good to the New World, and they only tortured , and butchered the Indians, they stole their gold, infected the Native Americans with smallpox, and left little but misery behind. Our text agrees with it to an extent. Although the Spanish did plunder, kill, and infect the natives they also left a diverse new culture. 




Questions you have to know:



Identity – How did the identities of colonizing and indigenous American societies change as a result of contact in the Americas?



Work, Exchange, and Technology – How did the Columbian Exchange – the mutual transfer of material goods, commodities, animals, and diseases – affect interaction between Europeans and natives and among indigenous peoples in North America?



Peopling – Where did different groups settle in the Americas (before contact) and how and why did they move to and within the Americas (after contact)? 

The three main reasons for coming to America are the three G's (God Glory and Gold). Jamestown was settled for gold. 

Politics and Power – How did Spain’s early entry into colonization in the Caribbean, Mexico, and South America shape European and American developments in this period?



America in the World – How did European attempts to dominate the Americas shape relations between Native Americans, Europeans, and Africans?



Environment and Geography – How did pre-contact populations of North America relate to their environments?  How did contact with Europeans and Africans change these relations in North America?





Ideas, Beliefs, and Cultures – How did cultural contact challenge the religious and other values systems of peoples from the Americas, Africa, and Europe?